Property Insurance

With a legacy that spans over 135 years, you will know that your property is in good hands. You’ll have experienced, local agents who know your community and are always here when you need us! Enjoy savings from a policyholder-owned company that offers: homeowner’s insurance, mobile home insurance, and renter’s insurance.

Farm Insurance

It’s hard to put a price tag on experience, especially in the insurance industry. With our farm-knowledgeable agents, you’ll have peace of mind knowing you’re getting the best price. You’ll also have a policy that’s customized to your specific farm property needs. We offer coverage for: farms, dwellings, barns, silos, farm machinery, livestock, and more!

Second Property Insurance

When insuring rental property or seasonal property, there are different needs and risks that have to be addressed. You can count on our experienced agents to ensure your specific property is thoroughly analyzed to maximize your value. Get year-round protection on seasonal dwelling insurance, rental property insurance, and vacant home insurance.


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Bradford County Agents

Charles Castle – 570-673-5666
Tom D’Angelo – 570-297-4165
Tom Elliott – 570-265-5876
Jim Hepp – 570-297-4165
Ed Johnson – 570-746-9025
Kim Mastrantonio – 570-888-2669
Gerald Pratt – 570-673-8217
Bruce Roy – 570-537-2447
Loren Roy – 570-549-3985

Potter County Agent

Jeremy Fowler – 814-435-7732

Columbia County Agent

Allan Harvey – 570-925-5081

Tioga County Agents

Tom D’Angelo – 570-662-7300
Jim Hepp – 570-662-7300

Susquehanna County Agent

Ed Johnson – 570-278-3743

Sullivan County Agent

Burton Adams – 570-928-9515

Insurance Experience You Can Trust

That might just be an understatement. You’ll have an agency that has been serving the region since 1877. Whatever your property insurance needs, you can count on local agents with the know how to come through for you.

Grinnell Mutual Logo

Contact Us

Address: P.O. Box 121
Troy, PA 16947
Phone: 570-297-4779
Toll Free: 800-297-1877
Fax: 570-297-4797